按主题
按用户名
按昵称
按相册
主题:SONY α350 和 CANON 450D 哪个更好?
188
0
来自:上海
注册:2005-05-16
发帖:25+204
偶是新手想入个入门级的, 看了几天, 决定就在这两款里选了.
原因就是都带防抖
没打算为入门级的再买啥头, 想来要买头的时候也该换主机了
有几个问题:
1, 它们的除尘功能真的有效吗? 哪个更强
2, 售后保修有何区别
3, 据说SONY性价比更高?
4, CANON的双套头与SONY的双套头比哪个更好啊?EF-S 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 IS和EF-S 55-250mm F4-5.6
5, 最傻的问题 - 可以定时拍摄吗
Option A:
索尼(SONY)α350W单反数码相机 含:双头套装(18-70mm F3.5-5.6/75-300mm F4.5-5.6)
¥5,877.00
Option B:
佳能(Canon)450D 单反数码相机套机(EF-S18-55/3.5-5.6IS镜头)赠:单反相机包
¥5,199.00
Canon EOS 1000D / XS with Canon EF-S 18-55mm IS
Canon EOS 450D / XSi with Canon EF-S 18-55mm IS
Canon EOS 400D / XTi with Canon EF-S 18-55mm
Sony Alpha DSLR-A350 with Sony DT 18-70mm
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-18 22:17:43
1794
29
来自:上海
等级:黄金目
注册:2001-01-05
发帖:211+4553
光看机身
a350比450D要好
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
无畏前路崎岖 无畏暴风骤雨
无论黎明黑夜 无论平原沙漠
依然傲然极速之美
发表于:2008-08-18 22:28:15
1524
1001
来自:上海
等级:黄金目
注册:2004-05-05
发帖:74+13070
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
哦也
发表于:2008-08-18 22:30:57
966
20
来自:上海
注册:2002-11-12
发帖:84+1265
哟,SONYa350还是双头乃
为撒不再加个D80一起对比
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-18 22:56:37
218
0
来自:上海
注册:2007-08-22
发帖:138+1074
这个
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
人生不息,装B不止
发表于:2008-08-18 23:11:35
218
0
来自:上海
注册:2007-08-22
发帖:138+1075
图没贴上来
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
人生不息,装B不止
发表于:2008-08-18 23:14:44
120
1
来自:保密
注册:2006-08-13
发帖:12+943
450D没有防抖的
新人选机还是看镜头比较好
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-19 08:06:18
351
4
来自:上海
注册:2006-10-30
发帖:128+1131
D80不错。现在价格降下来了。
在网上看到,三镜套机6000+
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MSN:skybadboy1981@hotmail.com
qq:75917265 
淘宝:http://store.taobao.com/shop/view_shop.htm?user_id=9334db454b8171b372575956374072b5
发表于:2008-08-19 08:51:01
32
0
来自:上海
等级:石头目
注册:2008-01-27
发帖:0+107
机身性能啊指标啊a350好一点,
但是整个系统,镜头选择余地等,Canon大很多;
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Canon 40D, 24-105mm F4L IS, 35mm F1.4L, 580EX II, Canon G7
我的相册:http://btbtshu.yupoo.com/
发表于:2008-08-19 10:45:52
190
0
来自:上海
注册:2005-05-16
发帖:25+205
^O^ 那就是说索尼拍的PP比佳能好? 刚刚去sony数码,店里说350的 75-300头只适拍肖像,不是长焦.350只是性价比高而已,听得偶一一凉~ (再次强调,不考虑额外加镜头,只买官方套装,毕竟入门级嘛)
看看cameralabs的测评总比, 实力不相上下啊:
引用:
SONY A350 评测
Good points /优点
Built-in anti-shake - works with any lens.
No-fuss Live View with quick AF.
Tilting monitor.
InfoLithium battery gives accurate feedback.
Bad points /缺点:
Relatively small optical viewfinder.
Modest 2.5fps continuous shooting.
Live View not 100% accurate.
Anti-dust system not effective in our tests
得分:
Build quality: 17 / 20
Image quality: 18 / 20
Handling: 18 / 20
Specification: 18 / 20
Value: 17 / 20
Overall: 88%
CANON EOS 450D
Good points /优点
Good handling and image quality.
Decent viewfinder and accurate Live View.
Kit includes stabilised lens.
PC remote control software supplied.
Bad points / 缺点
Live View not as fuss-free as Sony A350.
Screen fixed in position, unlike A350.
Some may find it too small and light.
Tempting to upgrade further to EOS 40D.
得分:
Build quality: 17 / 20
Image quality: 19 / 20
Handling: 18 / 20
Specification: 17 / 20
Value: 17 / 20
Overall: 88%
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-19 19:25:50
699
0
来自:上海
等级:白银目
注册:2001-03-25
发帖:75+657
入门机我觉得没必要考虑镜头群有多大,到了要考虑镜头群的时候无论是350还是450都已经不适合你了,现在考虑的就应该是性价比
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
潜水ing……
发表于:2008-08-19 20:40:27
190
0
来自:上海
注册:2005-05-16
发帖:25+206
引用: 入门机我觉得没必要考虑镜头群有多大,到了要考虑镜头群的时候无论是350还是450都已经不适合你了,现在考虑的就应该是性价比
那就是SONY喽
?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-19 20:55:59
353
4
来自:上海
等级:白银目
注册:2006-10-30
发帖:128+1133
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
MSN:skybadboy1981@hotmail.com
qq:75917265 
淘宝:http://store.taobao.com/shop/view_shop.htm?user_id=9334db454b8171b372575956374072b5
发表于:2008-08-20 08:59:18
365
0
来自:上海
等级:白银目
注册:2003-02-26
发帖:130+831
就一个ccd就和cmos差很远了,索尼那套头也是小光圈,光线不够的时候,快门速度不够肯定要开高iso,索尼那个防抖有毛用了?iso拉到1600看看画质?
还是选择450D吧
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QQ:32871
发表于:2008-08-20 11:16:35
528
2997
来自:上海
注册:2007-01-19
发帖:510+4358
450D 保险点
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-20 12:27:51
1281
11
来自:上海
等级:黄金目
注册:2000-12-26
发帖:679+5594
当然选450D啦,谁规定入门机就不能上好头了,楼主应该再比较下L头和蔡斯头哪个性价比高,毕竟原配的头估计楼主也用不下去的。我觉得还是450D+适马18-50/2.8比较合算。
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
酒醒只在花前坐 酒醉换来花下眠
半醒半醉日复日 花落花开年复年
发表于:2008-08-20 14:32:35
192
0
来自:上海
注册:2005-05-16
发帖:25+207
晕了, 看了SONY的广告, 貌似那个可以翻转的LCD很实用,论画质,好像CANON拍出来的更好一点?
引用:
but at least the noise levels remain pretty much matched to the earlier 400D / XTi – which gives both cameras an advantage over the Sony A350 which appears noisier than the Canons at higher sensitivities.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-20 16:04:39
31
3
来自:北京
等级:石头目
注册:2007-12-09
发帖:3+133
lz就算再入门,除非很快更新机身,否则绝对要考虑镜头群的
像sony的镜头。。。。连a口的镜头都不好买。。。
除非lz铁定心思入任何镜头,否则还是选择450D或者D80要好得多
有亲身经历的
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Canon EOS 1000D
18-55 IS 55-250 IS 50mm/1.8
一套狗头扫天下...!
发表于:2008-08-20 19:02:35
365
0
来自:上海
等级:白银目
注册:2003-02-26
发帖:130+835
买sony的初衷是为了当傻瓜机用吧
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QQ:32871
发表于:2008-08-20 19:44:24
365
0
来自:上海
等级:白银目
注册:2003-02-26
发帖:130+836
引用: 晕了, 看了SONY的广告, 貌似那个可以翻转的LCD很实用,论画质,好像CANON拍出来的更好一点?
引用: but at least the noise levels remain pretty much matched to the earlier 400D / XTi – which gives both cameras an advantage over the Sony A350 which appears noisier than the Canons at higher sensitivities.
sony的高端a700和a900恐怕没有这种可翻转的LCD设计吧?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
QQ:32871
发表于:2008-08-20 19:47:28
17
0
来自:上海
注册:2007-09-24
发帖:6+67
引用: 偶是新手想入个入门级的, 看了几天, 决定就在这两款里选了. 原因就是都带防抖 没打算为入门级的再买啥头, 想来要买头的时候也该换主机了 有几个问题:1, 它们的除尘功能真的有效吗? 哪个更强 2, 售后保修有何区别 3, 据说SONY性价比更高? 4, CANON的双套头与SONY的双套头比哪个更好啊?EF-S 18-55mm F3.5-5.6 IS和EF-S 55-250mm F4-5.6 5, 最傻的问题 - 可以定时拍摄吗 Option A: 索尼(SONY)α350W单反数码相机 含:双头套装(18-70mm F3.5-5.6/75-300mm F4.5-5.6) ¥5,877.00 Option B: 佳能(Canon)450D 单反数码相机套机(EF-S18-55/3.5-5.6IS镜头)赠:单反相机包 ¥5,199.00Canon EOS 1000D / XS with Canon EF-S 18-55mm IS
Canon EOS 450D / XSi with Canon EF-S 18-55mm IS
Canon EOS 400D / XTi with Canon EF-S 18-55mm
Sony Alpha DSLR-A350 with Sony DT 18-70mm
绝对支持A350
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-20 21:21:49
194
0
来自:上海
注册:2005-05-16
发帖:25+208
引用:
sony的高端a700和a900恐怕没有这种可翻转的LCD设计吧?
的确SONY的中端(700等只能认为是中端)机并有这种设计. 但对于从消费级DC过渡到单反的入门用户而言,可翻转的LV无疑是人性化的设计.
最近也在翻阅一些摄影杂志, 上面也谈了两款的测评,最夸张的还有把SONY 350与 PENTAX K20D作比较
.
总结下来, SONY易操作(傻瓜化), 操作CANON则需要摄影者技术.
所以偶的决定还在挣扎中....
引用:
摘自:CAMERALABS.COM
Canon’s EOS 450D / Rebel XSi is likely to be the biggest rival to the Sony A350, with both kits costing pretty much the same. The Alpha A350 stands-up very well against the Canon in terms of features, with two extra Megapixels, a tiltable screen, quicker AF in Live View, and built-in stabilisation which works with any lens you attach. And the Sony kit lens is slightly longer too, zooming into 70mm compared to the Canon’s 55mm.
In its favour, the Canon 450D / XSi has a slightly bigger 3in screen (albeit fixed in position), quicker 3.5fps continuous shooting, 14-bit image processing, a bigger viewfinder, mirror lockup, a depth-of-field preview button, and a Live View mode which may be slower, but features both a contrast-based AF option and a true preview of what you’ll be capturing from the main sensor. You also get PC remote control software which includes a live on-screen preview. It’s a tough one to weigh-up, but the Alpha A350 arguably has the edge for general buyers while the 450D / XSi will probably appeal to the more technically demanding photographers. See our Canon EOS 450D / Rebel XSi review for more details.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-21 11:27:06
1180
0
来自:上海
等级:黄金目
注册:2001-10-02
发帖:306+3194
lz和偶的疑问一样啊,难啊,现在看看1000D的性价比更高啊,更难选了
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
喜欢听快门咔嚓声……
发表于:2008-08-21 14:34:00
194
0
来自:上海
注册:2005-05-16
发帖:25+209
引用: lz和偶的疑问一样啊,难啊,现在看看1000D的性价比更高啊,更难选了
1000D 的性价比是高.
但与450D比,现在我宁愿多出几百块:
Build quality: 16 / 20
Image quality: 18 / 20
Handling: 16 / 20
Specification: 16 / 20
Value: 16 / 20
Overall: 82% (总分)
又看了下CANON的广告,终于决定了,以后走\"准专业\"路线, CANON EOS 450D, 操作不方便没关系, 可以慢慢学
YOUTOBE 上的佳能450D广告
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
这个家伙很懒,什么也没留下......
发表于:2008-08-21 15:09:39
243
0
来自:上海
注册:2004-12-15
发帖:72+620
不要和佳能谈性价比,佳能就是靠高端机撑市面,让不明白的人认为佳能的低端机【应该】也很不错。
广告做得最多的产品,其质量并不一定是最高的,价格也肯定不是最合理的。(不理解这句话,可以看看脑白金的广告投放量)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
发表于:2008-08-21 15:26:14